Case file · High strangeness
The Nimrod Islands
In 1828 Captain Eilbeck of the ship Nimrod, sailing from Sydney towards Cape Horn, reported a group of islands at about 56°S 158°W that later searches never found.
1828 CE · -56.00, -158.00 · status: explained
The account
The islands were placed between the equally phantom Emerald Island and Dougherty Island. Shackleton's Nimrod (a different ship of the same name) searched the region in 1909 without success.
The sceptical view
Like the other phantoms of this route, most likely icebergs, cloud banks or a navigational error.