Case file · Cryptid

The Myakka skunk ape photographs

In 2000 the Sarasota County Sheriff's Office in Florida received two anonymous photos of a large, hairy, ape-like animal at night, with a letter from a woman who said it had been stealing apples from her porch.

2000 CE · 27.24, -82.31 · status: disputed

The account

The writer, claiming to be an elderly woman living near Interstate 75, said she feared it was an escaped orangutan. The 'Myakka photos', named after the nearby state park, became the best-known images of Florida's skunk ape, a reeking Bigfoot of the south-eastern swamps. In 1997 a fire chief's photograph in Big Cypress National Preserve was followed within weeks by dozens of reported sightings.

The sceptical view

The sender was never identified and the animal's features fit an orangutan or a person in a costume. Florida has occasional escaped exotic animals, and black bears explain many swamp sightings.

The researched reading

Two anonymous flash photos of an ape-like figure: a costume or an escaped orangutan. There is no evidence of an unknown animal.

ExplanationWeightWhy
Undetermined50%The share the reading had given to fabrication on doubt rather than evidence: the record does not settle it either way.
Something known, misidentified30%The letter itself suggested an escaped orangutan, and the features fit one. Florida has had escaped exotic primates, and black bears explain many swamp sightings.
Perception, memory or mind6%Flash photos at night distort size and shape.
A hoax or fabrication5%The sender was anonymous and never found, and no one else saw the animal. The photos show a figure in a fixed pose that many analysts compare to a person in a costume.
A cultural story5%Skunk-ape lore shaped how the photos were received.
An unknown or out-of-place animal3%An unknown North American ape has no physical evidence.
Genuinely anomalous1%Not applicable.

Official position: The sheriff’s office received the photos; no investigation identified the source.

Connections in the atlas

Sources

  1. Wikipedia: Skunk ape
  2. Orangutan (Wikipedia)
Open it in the living atlas