Case file · Apparition / miracle

The Uganda Martyrs of Namugongo

On 3 June 1886, on the orders of Kabaka Mwanga II of Buganda, a group of young Christian converts, including Charles Lwanga, were burned alive at Namugongo.

1886 CE · 0.41, 32.65 · status: official

The account

Between 1885 and 1887, 22 Catholics and 23 Anglicans were killed. The Catholic martyrs were canonised in 1964, and each 3 June more than a million pilgrims, many walking for weeks from Kenya, Tanzania and beyond, come to the shrine at Namugongo. Healings and answered prayers are reported there.

The sceptical view

The executions are documented history; healings attributed to the martyrs are matters of faith.

The researched reading

The martyrdom is history; the healings are matters of devotion with no medical record. Expectation and ordinary recovery explain them.

ExplanationWeightWhy
Perception, memory or mind35%Healing reports at mass pilgrimages come mostly from expectation, emotional release and the placebo response, which can ease pain and functional symptoms.
A cultural story33%Namugongo is a national and regional shrine, and stories of answered prayers are part of the devotion that brings over a million pilgrims each June.
A known natural phenomenon25%Among a million pilgrims many illnesses will get better on their own or with treatment, and recoveries get counted while failures do not.
Genuinely anomalous4%No healing has been medically documented and published.
A hoax or fabrication3%No evidence of organised fakery.

Official position: The executions are documented history; the Catholic martyrs were canonised in 1964 (the canonisation miracles were not those of the shrine).

Connections in the atlas

Sources

  1. Wikipedia: Uganda Martyrs
  2. Placebo (Wikipedia)
Open it in the living atlas