Case file · High strangeness

The Arthur's Seat coffins

In June 1836 boys hunting rabbits on Arthur's Seat, Edinburgh, found a hidden niche holding 17 tiny wooden coffins, each with a carved and clothed wooden figure.

1836 CE · 55.94, -3.16 · status: unexplained

The account

Eight survive in the National Museum of Scotland. Theories include witchcraft, sailors' charms and a memorial to the 17 victims of the murderers Burke and Hare in 1827–28.

The sceptical view

The Burke and Hare idea fits the number but not the sex of the victims; the purpose remains unknown.

The researched reading

A real and moving puzzle of human intent. Seventeen carved figures were buried with care, most likely as a memorial or a ritual. Who made them is unknown, but how and roughly when are not mysterious.

ExplanationWeightWhy
Undetermined45%The share the reading had given to fabrication on doubt rather than evidence: the record does not settle it either way.
A cultural story40%The coffins are real hand-made objects, and the question is human meaning, not physics. Later study of the surviving eight found 1830s cloth and consistent workmanship, possibly by one person with shoemaker’s tools. That fits a private memorial (perhaps to Burke and Hare’s victims), a substitute burial for people lost at sea, or folk magic.
A hoax or fabrication5%A prank or a made-up curiosity is possible, since the boys who found them broke several and the press made the most of the find. However, the careful work and the hidden placement argue against a joke.
Perception, memory or mind4%The objects are physical, so perception explains only how they have been read, such as the claims of witchcraft.
Something in the surroundings2%Nothing about the surroundings is in question. Listed only for completeness.
A known natural phenomenon2%Natural processes explain only the decay of the coffins, not their making.
Genuinely anomalous2%Their purpose is unknown, but nothing about them is physically inexplicable.

Official position: The National Museum of Scotland holds the surviving coffins; their maker and purpose are officially unknown.

Sources

  1. Wikipedia: Arthur's Seat coffins
  2. Arthur’s Seat coffins (Wikipedia)
  3. Burke and Hare murders (Wikipedia)
Open it in the living atlas