Case file · Official inquiry

Black 'lozenge' at Gatwick

On 15 July 1991 a Britannia Airways Boeing 737 approaching Gatwick at 14,000 feet met a black lozenge-shaped object that passed about 30 feet above its wing.

1991 CE · 51.15, -0.18 · status: disputed

The account

The Civil Aviation Authority said it was 'probably a weather balloon'. The Met Office replied that its balloons are orange-red and do not drift at that height in that way.

The sceptical view

A party or advertising balloon remains the most likely answer.

The researched reading

A brief close pass by a small dark object. A stray balloon of a non-meteorological kind remains the best explanation.

ExplanationWeightWhy
Something known, misidentified50%A dark, lozenge-shaped object passing close at 14,000 feet with no radar return fits a toy, party or advertising balloon, or a balloon cluster, which can climb high and look solid at closing speed. The Met Office only ruled out its own orange weather balloons.
Genuinely anomalous12%The CAA could not identify it, but a small dark object seen briefly is not strong evidence of anything unknown.
Secret human technology10%A small military drone or test object is possible but unsupported; such systems were few in 1991.
Perception, memory or mind10%Seen for a second or two, size and distance are guesses, and "30 feet above the wing" may be much farther.
A known natural phenomenon5%Wind-borne debris such as plastic sheeting can reach surprising heights in convective weather.
Undetermined5%The share a generic explanation had beyond what has been shown for this case: it fits many cases like this one, but has not been demonstrated for this one.
A poorly understood natural phenomenon4%No atmospheric phenomenon is known to look like a black solid lozenge.
A hoax or fabrication4%The crew filed an official report; invention is unlikely.

Official position: The Civil Aviation Authority said it was "probably a weather balloon"; the Met Office disputed that its balloons could be involved.

Sources

  1. Wikipedia: UFO sightings in the United Kingdom
  2. Science Frontiers 96: another near miss
Open it in the living atlas