Case file · High strangeness

The Ossett exorcism killing

In October 1974, after an all-night exorcism by clergy at a church in Barnsley, Michael Taylor of Ossett, West Yorkshire, killed his wife Christine with extreme violence.

1974 CE · 53.68, -1.58 · status: official

The account

He was found not guilty by reason of insanity. The case led to calls for controls on exorcism and changes in Church of England guidance requiring medical consultation.

The sceptical view

Taylor was mentally ill; the case shows the dangers of treating illness as possession.

The researched reading

A killing after an exorcism, by a man whose mental illness was read as possession. Psychosis and a harmful ritual explain it.

ExplanationWeightWhy
Perception, memory or mind40%Michael Taylor was found not guilty by reason of insanity; his escalating agitation in the weeks before, and the all-night rite that told him he was full of demons, fit an acute psychotic episode made worse by suggestion.
A cultural story30%A charismatic prayer group and clergy framed his illness as possession; the case pushed the Church of England to require medical consultation before deliverance ministry.
Undetermined18%The share a generic explanation had beyond what has been shown for this case: it fits many cases like this one, but has not been demonstrated for this one.
A known natural phenomenon5%Sleep deprivation and exhaustion during the rite would have intensified a breakdown.
Genuinely anomalous3%The court record contains nothing beyond illness and belief.
Something in the surroundings2%No environmental factor is involved.
A hoax or fabrication2%No one faked anything; the clergy believed they were helping.

Official position: Taylor was found not guilty by reason of insanity; the case led to new Church of England guidance on exorcism.

Sources

  1. Wikipedia: Michael Taylor (British killer)
  2. Exorcism (Wikipedia)
Open it in the living atlas