Case file · High strangeness

The Sherman family's ranch reports

Terry and Gwen Sherman said that after buying a Uintah County cattle ranch they saw repeated UFOs, lights coming out of glowing doorways in mid-air, and lost cows to disappearance and mutilation.

1995 CE · 40.26, -109.89 · status: account

The account

The Shermans bought the property in 1994. By mid-1996 they described three kinds of craft seen over about 15 months, flattened grass circles, a light that followed Gwen's car, and male voices in an unknown language heard above Terry in a field while the dogs panicked. They said four cows vanished and three were found dead and partly mutilated. Later accounts added the claim that balls of light killed the family dogs.

The sceptical view

The county sheriffs told the Deseret News they had no recent reports of UFOs or mutilations, and the family had told no officials. Skeptic Robert Sheaffer notes that the previous owners, who lived there for about 60 years, denied any strange events, and argues the simplest explanation is that the story was made up before the ranch was sold.

The researched reading

A single family’s dramatic story, unreported to authorities at the time and denied by earlier owners. It reads more like a narrative than an evidence record.

Explanation	Weight	Why
Perception, memory or mind	24%	Isolation, stress over livestock losses and a local UFO tradition encourage reading ordinary losses and lights as a pattern.
Undetermined	23%	The share the reading had given to fabrication on doubt rather than evidence: the record does not settle it either way.
A hoax or fabrication	15%	The Shermans had told no officials; the sheriff’s office told the Deseret News it had no recent reports, the earlier owners denied any strangeness, and the ranch was sold soon after the story broke.
A cultural story	12%	The basin had decades of UFO lore and Ute traditions to draw on.
A known natural phenomenon	12%	Cattle losses on open range are usually predators, disease or theft.
Something in the surroundings	8%	Night lights over the Uinta Basin include aircraft, oil-field flares and vehicle lights on distant roads.
Genuinely anomalous	6%	A small share stays open for experiences that were sincerely reported, but none was documented.

Official position: No official investigation; local sheriffs said they had received no such reports.

Connections in the atlas

Sources

Open it in the living atlas