Case file · Apparition / miracle

Monica Besra's cure

On 5 September 1998 Monica Besra of South Dinajpur, West Bengal, said a tumour vanished after a locket with Mother Teresa's picture was placed on her; the Vatican accepted it as the miracle for Teresa's beatification in 2003.

1998 CE · 25.30, 88.80 · status: disputed

The sceptical view

Her doctors said she had tuberculosis treated with drugs over months, and that the cure was medical.

The researched reading

A mass that shrank after months of tuberculosis treatment. The medical explanation, which her own doctors gave, is far more likely than a miracle.

ExplanationWeightWhy
A known natural phenomenon50%Her treating doctors said the abdominal mass was tubercular and responded to months of anti-TB drugs. Tubercular masses do shrink with treatment, and her husband initially credited the medicine.
Undetermined21%The share the reading had given to fabrication on doubt rather than evidence: the record does not settle it either way.
A cultural story14%Mother Teresa’s canonisation was a major cause, and the case was promoted by her order. Diagnosis records were reportedly taken from the hospital.
Perception, memory or mind6%A sense of warmth and relief after prayer is real but does not shrink a mass.
A hoax or fabrication5%There are claims of pressure on doctors and records, but no proof of deliberate fabrication.
Genuinely anomalous4%The Vatican’s board deemed the cure inexplicable, but treating doctors disagree.

Official position: The Vatican accepted the cure as a miracle for Mother Teresa’s beatification in 2003.

Sources

  1. Wikipedia: Mother Teresa (beatification)
  2. Monica Besra (Wikipedia)
Open it in the living atlas