Case file · Non-fiction & research literature

The Missing 411 'profile points'

The recurring features Paulides lists for his cases: boulder fields, water, places already searched, missing shoes or clothes, sudden bad weather, dogs that cannot track, and people found far uphill.

2012 CE · 37.76, -119.56 · status: disputed

The account

Paulides marks each case against a set of shared features: the person vanished near a boulder field or water; was found, if at all, in an area searchers had already covered; was missing shoes or clothing; bad weather began just after the disappearance; tracking dogs lost the scent or refused to follow; a small child was found far away or high uphill; and the person was confused or could not remember what happened. He has also pointed to some people being very young, old, disabled, highly educated or of German ancestry. He presents these as a pattern without offering a cause. Lost-person research and medicine offer ordinary explanations for most of them, and analysts note that boulders, water and bad weather are found nearly everywhere in mountains.

The sceptical view

Paradoxical undressing in hypothermia explains missing clothes; children often climb rather than descend; searchers routinely miss a still person in thick cover; rain and snow destroy scent; and a list of cases that share features means little without counting the many cases that do not.

The researched reading

The cases are real and many are sad and unsolved, but the shared features are what lost-person research predicts, and no one has shown an unusual rate. The real finding of Missing 411 is a record-keeping gap, not a hidden cause.

Explanation	Weight	Why
A known natural phenomenon	38%	Falls, drowning, exposure and heat kill people every year in the same terrain; the Park Service alone runs thousands of searches a year, so a small share that end badly or never end is expected.
Perception, memory or mind	22%	Lost-person behaviour (children climbing, confused people walking into cover, hypothermic undressing and burrowing) explains most profile points directly.
A cultural story	18%	Selection and framing: cases are chosen because they fit, explanations and later findings are left out, and boulders, water and storms are present almost everywhere; analysts find no unusual rate.
Undetermined	16%	Many individual cases remain unsolved and some (Fugate, Bowman, Bechtel) may involve crime rather than the wild; the record-keeping gap means the true numbers are not known.
An unknown or out-of-place animal	4%	Known predators (mountain lions, bears) account for a few deaths, as in the Atadero case; this is a natural cause, not an unknown animal, and the share for anything unknown is very small.
Genuinely anomalous	2%	No case on the official record requires an unknown agent; the series implies one without evidence.

Official position: No agency recognises a Missing 411 pattern. The Park Service keeps no central list of the missing; Congress has moved to add a federal-land category to NamUs (TRACE Act, passed the Senate 2024).

Connections in the atlas

Sources

Open it in the living atlas