Case file · Haunting
Wood Island Light murder-suicide
In the 1890s a squatter on Wood Island in Saco Bay, Maine, shot a sheriff's deputy, was turned away when he tried to surrender to the lighthouse keeper, and killed himself. The deputy's ghost is said to haunt the island.
1896 CE · 43.46, -70.33 · status: legend
The account
Most local histories date the killing to 1896. The keeper at the time was Thomas Henry Orcutt. The lighthouse is Maine's second-oldest.
The sceptical view
The ghost legend is thinly sourced; Wikipedia gives only 'the 1890s' for the killing.