Case file · Cryptid

The Kiryat Yam mermaid

In August 2009 the town of Kiryat Yam near Haifa offered a reward of about one million dollars for proof of a mermaid after residents reported dozens of sightings off its beach.

2009 CE · 32.85, 35.06 · status: claim

The account

Council spokesman Natti Zilberman said a verifiable photograph would be enough. The council denied it was a publicity stunt but hoped the creature would bring tourists, and international media made the 'Israeli mermaid' a summer story. An American group claiming to defend mermaids' rights even threatened legal action against the town. The prize was never claimed, and no photograph or video has been authenticated.

The sceptical view

Dolphins and seals near the shore, sunset glare and the pull of a well-publicised reward explain the reports; the circulating videos are generally judged fake.

The researched reading

A modern mermaid flap driven by ordinary sea animals and a publicised reward; the individual sightings remain unexamined.

ExplanationWeightWhy
Something known, misidentified40%Dolphins, seals and swimmers seen at dusk off a busy beach, plus expectation once the story spread, fit the reports.
A cultural story35%The million-dollar reward and tourism hopes turned scattered reports into a media event that invited more sightings.
Undetermined25%The individual witnesses were never interviewed in depth, so what each saw is unknown.
An unknown or out-of-place animal0%No mammal resembling a mermaid is known or plausible in the eastern Mediterranean; NOAA notes no evidence of aquatic humanoids.

Official position: The Kiryat Yam council offered a reward; it was never claimed.

Connections in the atlas

Sources

  1. ABC News: Photograph Israeli mermaid, win $1 million
  2. JTA: Mermaid fever leads to lawsuit
  3. NOAA Ocean Facts
Open it in the living atlas